The Feminization of Librarianship
Since the proliferation of American public libraries began in the late nineteenth century, library work has been associated with women. As in other female dominated fields the salaries and benefits are less than those fields that associated with traditionally male skills and personality traits. When women initially entered the field in high numbers their economic options for professional and intellectual expression were limited and thus the role of the librarian was adopted as a female identity that fit conveniently into prevailing societal norms of a women as service-oriented nurturers.
The discussion about women in librarianship has often failed to address the root causes of divisions in gender that are wrongly assumed to be inherent. Librarians must address the roots of why femininity is debased in the workplace and also seek to illuminate the vast contributions women have made in the field.
Historically, women’s economic options have been decidedly limited as workers. In the late nineteenth century without many jobs available to educated women, male library administrators often accepted the employment of women as librarians and assistants as a means of allowing their organizations to survive financially. Access to alternate types of employment proved to be an important factor in attracting women to the profession. Male librarians at the time were accepting of incoming women simply for the cost-effective opportunity that they provided.
The common practice of undervaluing library work may be observed in both the low salaries of women who worked in libraries of the past and also in the salaries of modern librarians. While the gap in wages between genders may have significantly closed over the years, salaries as a whole have remained depressed for all individuals working in the field. To this day librarians remain one of the lowest paid individuals whose job requires an advanced degree besides social work (another field that is associated with women).
The opportunity for women to enter library school at Columbia College, later known as Columbia University, in 1887 proved to be a double-edmged sword in ters of women’s opportunity for advancement. Melvil Dewey (right) championed women as librarians and library school educators but placed caps on their achievement in terms of gender straight away. According to Dewey’s blatant double standard, women had to demonstrate truly remarkable ability or be relegated to perpetual underling status.
One such woman was Mary Wright Plummer, one of Dewey’s first library science students at Colombia. Born into a large prosperous Quaker family, Plummer had grown up feeling entitled to success alongside her male relatives. A former graduate of Wellesley, Plummer eventually went on to help launch the Pratt Institute Library School. Plummer eventually became the director of Pratt Institute’s Free Library. She also helped develop the first children’s room and began training librarians in youth services.
Other women served as library directors in the early nineteenth century as well. Katherine Sharp served as the director of the Armour Institute Library School in Chicago. Sharp instituted a requirement that students complete two years of college before being admitted and stressed that methodological teaching served library students best as opposed to abstract theory. Sharp also was a key player in encouraging the American Library Association to critique the performance of library schools.
Both Katherine Sharp and Mary Wright Plummer wanted their graduates to be successful and to fortify the profession of librarianship. They encouraged their students to maintain their school’s reputations and to develop successful careers advising library boards of trustees to keep librarian’s salaries at a high rate. Of course, this was not always the case for women when they found employment.
The process of assigning new labels to library science in order to help achieve status may be noted as a sexist move to shun the female-intensive aspects of their work. While higher paid managerial and technical jobs are popular choices for men, traditionally feminine jobs such as cataloguing or children’s services remain common choices for women in library science. The adaptation of library jobs to focus more on the maintenance and operation of computers rather than ethics of service is a clear indicator that the field has resisted the application of a feminine label.
In lieu of reassessing library work and labeling it with a technical label that gives it more credit for masculine attributes, aspects of library work that are associated with women must be given comparable value. While all aspects of library work deserve recognition, including both technical services and traditional areas like reference and children’s services, drawing binary lines between job roles invariably points to gender separation and lowered status for women.
History suggests that without question women have and do serve as leaders and innovators in the field despite obstacles placed on them in terms of gender expectation. The image of the librarian as a genteel and unassertive woman certainly has prevailed as time has progressed. The advent of new advancements in technology has also contributed to further divisions in library job descriptions. A new definition of value is called for in assigning worth to women’s contributions to library work. Rather than scrambling for professional status librarians must examine the larger cultural politics that perpetually create divisive dichotomies between men and women.
- Tawny Sverdlin's blog
- Login or register to post comments
I am happy to find so many
I am happy to find so many useful information here in the post, we need develop more strategies in this regard, thanks for sharing.
Penny stocks
The balance with the
The balance with the employee and creating social equity that benefits the worker so that he/she can fund and enjoy healthy living; proves to be a continuous revolving issue in westernized societies.Thanks for sharing the informative post. Regards. Commercial Property Sheffield
Still there is room for
Still there is room for greater development and I would recommend more emphasis on research and of course it will bring a better situation. Thanks for sharing a nice read. Cheers
Loose Natural Gemstones
Post is nicely written and
Post is nicely written and it contains many good things for me. I am glad to find your impressive way of writing the post. Now it become easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thanks for sharing the post.
auto air conditioning compressor
Fourth, the words at the end
Fourth, the words at the end of the Phaistos disk seem to be shorter than those at the outset, which would match the pattern found in various Ural-Altaic languages where the terminal words are frequently verbs of being or doing following longer participial and gerundive constructions.
Oahu Scuba Diving
Nicely presented information
Nicely presented information in this post, I prefer to read this kind of stuff. The quality of content is fine and the conclusion is good. Thanks for the post. Woman always do better as librarian. properties Dubai | Dubai apartments rent | villa Dubai
That is very good comment
That is very good comment you shared.Thank you so chat much that for you shared those things with us.Im wishing you chat sohbet to carry on with ur achivments.All the best .
Wow great, I am happy to
Wow great, I am happy to find it, Thanks for sharing it here. So you are thinking to go for gay marriage. :)
Phoenix Self Storage
Retailers are very wrong in
Retailers are very wrong in choosing the direction of the market / top and bottom. Most retailers seem very natural-take a stand against this trend and offers very precise signals for those seeking trade against this group. This daily report is designed to help marketers focus their efforts on the most likely pairs. Virus protection free
Driving jobs London
thanks alot.... Therxone
thanks alot.... Therxone
nice post
nice post
We will surely subscribe to
We will surely subscribe to this post,,, because of its very relevant topics that in searching searching for more....jewelry buyers Houston
Oh, and note that Nintendo
Oh, and note that Nintendo gets very low marks from Greenpeace, simply because they do not tell them what they use, not because they actually use a lot of harmful things (tho could) search engine optimization copywriting
I recommend to my foreign
I recommend to my foreign colleagues to start with a conservative approach and then, if you want to spend more high-frequency trading thay can do that later, once they acquire a little more experience.Theonerx
its so hard to be left all
its so hard to be left all alone!
Buy Assignment | Buy Thesis
Fall by the
Fall by the time
Dissertation Writing | Buy Admission Essay | Book Report
Everyone knows that women
Everyone knows that women read more, think more and are more inteligent than males. It therefore stands to reason that women should be in charge of our libaries. I always go away and stay in holiday cottages when I want to read any new books and leave my husband at home.
tomy baby monitor
I think there will always be
I think there will always be roles that although they can be fulfilled by either gender will be stereotyped to being primarily a position for one gender.
Excellent site, keep up the
Excellent site, keep up the good work my colleagues would love this. I read a lot of blogs on a daily basis and for the most part, people lack substance but, I just wanted to make a quick comment to say I’m glad I found your blog. make money on the internet Thanks
all your articles impress
all your articles impress me.keep up the great work here memory games
Well traditionally feminine
Well traditionally feminine jobs such as cataloging or children’s services remain common choices for women in library science. The adaptation of library jobs to focus more on the maintenance and operation of computers rather than ethics of service is a clear indicator. Free iPhone Apps
Well they encouraged their
Well they encouraged their students to maintain their school’s reputations and to develop successful careers advising library boards of trustees to keep librarian’s salaries at a high rate. Of course, this was not always the case for women when they found employment. wholesale handbags | learn futures trading | garment factory
This such a good read. You
This such a good read. You are so right about women dominating the librarian field. I would love to see a change to this.
mesothelioma lawyer columbus
Hey, thanks for your
Hey, thanks for your suggestion, man. Now I got a nice job and guess what?! The salary is nice, it's much better than my expectation. Libgig is surely rocks!
Cat harness
Briefs Underwear
Belinda Scheider
i second the thoughts
i second the thoughts already posted in the above comments.they are absolutely right
anxiety attacks floor steam cleaners extractors
Historically, women’s
Historically, women’s economic options have been decidedly limited as workers. The common practice of undervaluing library work may be observed in both the low salaries of women who worked in libraries of the past and also in the salaries of modern librarians. So I think you are right!
low carb food diets and low carb counter
Well, people tend to choose
Well, people tend to choose woman as librarian because they tend to be more tidy than mem, so I think it can't be help.
snoring remedies
Belinda Scheider
Agree 100% it's obvious but
Agree 100% it's obvious but often overlooked. curtains and blinds
male n females both are
male n females both are libral but the logical thing is that mostly proper divison in gender regarding education . Castlemaine accomodation
order zithromax online
order zithromax online
It’s good that you do such
It’s good that you do such superior thought close to this post. Hence we think that this would be great if scholars buy the thesis proposal and thesis with you help.
I must say that A former
I must say that A former graduate of Wellesley, Plummer eventually went on to help launch the Pratt Institute Library School. Plummer eventually became the director of Pratt Institute’s Free Library. She also helped develop the first children’s room and began training librarians in youth services.
Apartments for sale Milton Keynes
Well i think that Sharp
Well i think that Sharp instituted a requirement that students complete two years of college before being admitted and stressed that methodological teaching served library students best as opposed to abstract theory.
penny stocks
I like the foundation of
I like the foundation of this blog has a great
variety of comments I really like it, , is very interesting and I would like learn more.
Dental Implants Bristol
The text just about this
The text just about this post was really popular and because of it the custom writing service will offer not very expensive custom papers and people buy custom essay papers.
Women has the powerful
Women has the powerful leadership in the society and we know that man build up the expected manners due to women. Moscow hotels | Online Admission | quang cao google
Women read more and study
Women read more and study more than man and she play the solid role in society in every manners . mcp | mcsa
I think that the women
I think that the women mental power is much than man because she has awareness and all credit goes to girl she sometimes give the right direction to the man . mcitp | mcts
Everyone knows that women
Everyone knows that women read more, think more and are more inteligent than males. It therefore stands to reason that women should be in charge of our libaries. I always go away and stay in holiday cottages when I want to read any new books and leave my husband at home.
Adult Movies
hello admin, I found your
hello admin, I found your blog from yahoo and read a few of your other posts.They are awesome. Please keep it up!!
_____________________________________
(copy xbox 360 games | wow gold guide | xbox 360 repair guide )
hello admin, I found your
hello admin, I found your blog from yahoo and read a few of your other posts.They are awesome. Please keep it up!!
_____________________________________
(copy xbox 360 games | wow gold guide | xbox 360 repair guide )
hello admin, I found your
hello admin, I found your blog from yahoo and read a few of your other posts.They are awesome. Please keep it up!!
_____________________________________
(copy xbox 360 games | wow gold guide | xbox 360 repair guide )
Everyone knows that women
Everyone knows that women read more, think more and are more inteligent than males. It therefore stands to reason that women should be in charge of our libaries. I always go away and stay in holiday cottages when I want to read any new books and leave my husband at home.
Banner Stands San Diego
It is without a doubt that
It is without a doubt that women have blazed the trail for the leadership in today's library system. I don't think this should be frowned upon as the role femininity has played is one that hardly any man would be willing or able to play. It is a tribute of the achievements of women in my view.
Vera Bradley
I like the foundation of
I like the foundation of this blog has a great variety of comments I really like it, several points of view helps in the appreciation of the subject,is very interesting and I would like learn more. cash gifting | forex trading system | make money on the internet
I agree. Women do love to
I agree. Women do love to read a lot more then men do. So women should be in charge of library and other stuff like that.
e-cigarette starter kits
I think in most of the
I think in most of the libraries around the world you gonna find only women work there. In my country there is no one single man works in library and if you found a man, the people start staring at him like he is doing something wrong.
العاب فلاش
Good post,I think
Good post,I think so!abercrombie and fitch on Sale, Hoodies, Jeans, T-Shirts, Pants, Polos hollister abercrombie outlethollister clothing Abercrombie Men Tee abercrombie womens polos Ruehl No.925, Men, women, and children's clothing. abercrombie and fitch , chat ,abercrombie and fitch and abercrombie and fitchfashion is bold and interesting, all thanks to the interestingand original designs of Don cinsel sohbet.
Surely women have
Surely women have contributed a lot to librarianship over the centuries but times are changing in this field as well.. We have a man librarian in our town as well beside a few women. Anyway, thank you for the good read!
orlando water damage
Everyone knows that women
Everyone knows that women read more, think more and are more inteligent than males. It therefore stands to reason that women should be in charge of our libaries. I always go away and stay in holiday cottages when I want to read any new books and leave my husband at home.
e cigarette